Best Ice Makers

Top 10 Rated Under Counter Ice Makers 2015

By

As we picked the top 10 ice makers, we looked for models that:

1. Produced ice quickly and efficiently
2. Were easy to install
3. Could be under the counter or freestanding
4. Had removable bins with ample ice storage
5. Stayed cold enough and were properly insulated
6. Didn’t have condensation or frost buildup
7. Ran relatively quietly

You can find some ice makers that produce about 12 pounds of ice a day for a couple hundred dollars; these models may be sufficient for the average family. The larger ice makers with greater ice production and special controls typically cost at least $1,000; these more expensive models are suited to heavy use. See the ice maker comparison and ratings below with a link to the full review of each.

Stainless steel
50 lbs. ice production per day
25 lbs. capacity
34.375” H x 14.875” W x 25.375” D

If you’re looking for an efficient, well-performing ice maker, then you’ll likely be happy with the Whirlpool GI15NDXZS, which produces up to 50 pounds of ice each day. We were satisfied… read more


Danby DPC6012BLS  8.5/10

Color: Stainless Steel
8 pounds ice storage
123.5 pounds
34 7/16″ x 23 13/16″ x 23 11/16″

If you like keeping your wine bottles and beverage cans chilled and ready to serve, then you’ll appreciate this undercounter ice maker from Danby with compartments for 8 pounds of … read more


Maxx Ice MIM75  8.5/10

Stainless steel
75 lbs. daily ice production
25 lbs. capacity
32.5” H x 16.5” W x 21.38” D

If you have need of an ice maker that makes a tremendous amount of ice, then look no further than the Maxx Ice MIM75, which produces up to 75 pounds of ice daily. It has a 25 pound capacity… read more


Color: Stainless Steel
50 pounds daily ice production
98 pounds
24.4″ x 14.9″ x 34.4″

A stylish, flat stainless steel door lets this Whirlpool ice maker blend in with the surrounding cabinets. Its ice production is fast, with clear, clean-looking cubes. The capacity is quite large, able to store 25 … read more


Summit BIM44  8/10

Color: Stainless Steel
44 pounds daily ice production
116 pounds
33.5″ x 14.6″ x 23″

For $1,099, this undercounter ice maker produces up to 44 pounds of ice a day. Its adjustable ice bin stores 25 pounds. With an automatic shut-off feature, you don’t have to worry about the bin overflowing … read more


Stainless steel
51 lbs. daily ice production
35 lbs. capacity
34.375” H x 17.875” W x 25.625” D

We were impressed by how the KitchenAid KUIC18NNZS produces up to 51 pounds of clear, uniform ice each day. It has a 35-pound capacity, which means it can store lots of ice for parties and other events… read more


EdgeStar IB120SS  7.5/10

Color: Stainless steel door and black cabinet
12 pounds daily ice production
54 pounds
25 1/4″ x 15″ x 18 1/2″

A reversible stainless steel door with a handle bar, this ice maker from EdgeStar can be installed either under a counter or freestanding. No drain line is necessary, and the front ventilation system allows it to be built in easily … read more


Stainless steel
50 lbs. daily ice production
25 lbs. capacity
34.375” H x 14.875” W x 25.375” D

If you’re looking for a convenient, efficient ice maker, the Maytag MIM1555ZRS fits the bill nicely. With 25 pounds of capacity, it produces up to 50 pounds of ice a day. We appreciated that this Maytag… read more


Color: Stainless steel door and black cabinet
12 pounds daily ice production
60 pounds
18″ x 15″ x 25″

This Sunpentown ice maker, which runs for $334.90, has an attractive stainless steel door and plain black cabinet. With a front ventilation system, it can be installed under a cabinet with a plumber’s assistance … read more



 

Ice Maker Buying Guide

If your refrigerator does not include an ice maker, or if you entertain frequently and need extra ice, then a home ice maker can be a valuable appliance. The undercounter style ice maker is designed to fit under the counter in a kitchen or bar, or it can sit as a freestanding unit.

Ice production

Determine how much ice you need daily. If you have a small or average sized family, then a small model that makes about 12 pounds of ice daily may be perfectly adequate. If you entertain guests often or have need of a lot of ice, then you can find machines that produce larger quantities, some up to 125 pounds a day. The price will also go up with the greater ice production. Decent to high-performing ice makers range from $300 to $2000.

Ice shape and clarity

Ice makers typically produce crescent-shaped ice cubes like refrigerator ice makers. There are also some models that make cubed, bullet-shaped, flake, or nugget pieces of ice. Some models allow you to adjust the thickness and density of the ice cubes.

Some people worry that ice makers produce cloudy ice due to water impurities. In actuality, if the ice turns out cloudy or white, it’s because ice makers freeze the ice much faster than clear ice cube makers, trapping air bubbles in the process. Many built-in ice makers produce clear ice, however, if that is your preference.

Speed of production

Undercounter ice makers typically make ice faster than clear ice makers. However, they’re usually not as quick as the portable variety.

Installation and maintenance

Built-in ice makers should be installed by a licensed plumber because they have to be properly hooked up to a water line or a drain line. Some undercounter ice makers must be installed over or near a gravity drain. If a gravity drain is not available in your home, you will need to purchase a pump to move the water to a drain or sink.

Undercounter ice makers without a storage bin will require you to periodically drain the melted water manually. However, there are many undercounter models that possess and keep the storage bin at freezing temperatures and do not require a drain. For many models, installation is especially simple with only a 115-volt power source and a water inlet line required.

Air-cooled or water-cooled

There are two systems for cooling the compressor or condenser in the ice machine: air or water.

  • Air-cooled systems are less expensive, but their warm exhaust air can heat up the room quickly and they operate quite noisily.
  • Water-cooled systems are more expensive but run efficiently and quietly. However, they can be costly to operate if your area has high water prices.
Brittany Rowland Brittany Rowland researches new developments in Appliances, Kitchen and CE products features with a vigor to which few would aspire… but someone has to do it. See more about Brittany

Featured Ice Maker Articles

Cleaning Your Icemaker

Cleaning Your Icemaker

Properly cleaning and maintaining your ice maker will ensure a long life for the appliance. If you’re using the ice maker in your bar or in a professional establishment, then it’s especially important to keep the components in working order…. [more]

Different Types of Ice Cubes Made By Ice Makers

Different Types of Ice Cubes Made by Ice Makers

Ice is ice, you might be thinking. What does it matter what shape or color it’s in? You’d be surprised to know that many food industry establishments, businesses, and private homes consider the shape and clarity of the ice they want when purchasing an ice maker… [more]

More Best Ice Makers

Filed Under: AppliancesIce MakersTop 10 Lists